Friday, June 7, 2013

REVIEW: Physicians Formula Eyeliner Trio VS Etude House Proof 10 Eyeliner VS Essence Longlasting Eye pencil



Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Eye Color Enhancing Eyeliner Trio 
Etude House Proof 10 Auto Eyeliner pencil

Essence Long lasting Eye pencil

Sorry for the back flash, I was taking pictures in the evening.
Up close photo of the three brave brand fighters.

ALL AUTO EYE PENCILS. NO NEED TO SHARPEN. 

I swatched them all 5x. So they're all pretty much been used. Let's see who has more product inside.........

I really don't know why Physician's Formula have different textures, the pink one tends to melt more than the other 2 colors.
Etude House has a blunt tip, and is shorter than the other 2 brands.
Essence has the same length with Physician's Formula liners, but is creamier in texture. Tends to break easily, lightly apply on surface.

Which one is the best? Essence? Physician's Formula? Etude House?




Category                                                          Essence             Physician's Formula      Etude House
 creamy                                                               ***                                        **                                      *         
pigmentation                                                     ***                                       ***                                     **     
water-proof                                                           *                                         ***                                    ***
smudge-proof                                                      *                                         **                                      ***
           long-lasting                                                           *                                        ***                                    **                       
eyeliner length                                                     ***                                        **                                     *        

Price:                                                                        Php109                       Php500 (3pcs)                  Php148

WINNER: Physician's Formula
 
      

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Please feel free to comment down! Have a wonderful day :)